Royal Treatment
Wednesday, April 15 2026 @ 12:01 AM EDT
Contributed by: June Northey
A special thing today - a guest column by Sean McLaughlin. He is a published author who has written a book about Jackie Robinson.
Eighty years ago this March, a 27-year-old middle infielder with just half a season’s worth of professional games under his belt was thrust into the spotlight of Branch Rickey’s Great Experiment to re-integrate Major League Baseball. To the surprise of no one, that Brooklyn Dodgers farmhand, Jackie Robinson, had an abysmal experience in Jim Crow Florida over the course of spring training. He endured a credible death threat, got the cold shoulder from plenty of his teammates, and he was even escorted off the field mid-game by a cop enforcing segregation law. Then local officials just started padlocking fields before games in which he was scheduled to play. Robinson grew so indignant in one angry outburst to his wife, Rachel, and his handler, Wendell Smith, that he even threatened to walk away from baseball entirely. They ultimately calmed him down and talked him out of pulling the plug on the Great Experiment. The emotional weight of it all understandably carried over onto the field and even Robinson’s most ardent defenders understood that he needed some minor league seasoning to develop his flashy tools before anyone could seriously talk about him joining the Dodgers.
That opportunity would come north of the border with the Montreal Royals of the AAA International League, the crown jewel franchise in the Dodgers’ farm system. There would be no triumphant debut for Jackie Robinson in iconic Dodgers blue and white at Ebbets Field on the date you all know, April 15, 1947, without a successful trial up north in Canada over the course of the 1946 season. In the grander picture, Jackie Robinson, Brooklyn Dodger, was the first domino of a series in the long postwar phase of the American Civil Rights Movement. Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. once called him “a pilgrim that walked in the lonesome byways toward the high road of Freedom. He was a sit-inner before sit-ins, a freedom rider before freedom rides.” Robinson’s highly symbolic integration of America’s pastime brought an end to segregation in the military by executive order from Harry Truman. Next came the Supreme Court’s Brown v. Board of Education ruling against "separate but equal” in schools. Under President Lyndon Johnson, Congress passed the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act, bringing the biggest wins of all against discrimination in hiring in housing and at the ballot box.
It all started with Jackie, and Jackie got started in Montreal.
Back in early 1946, baseball fans in Quebec read about the indignities Robinson faced in Florida and immediately decided that they were going to become active participants in his struggle. They rallied around him for what he represented — change and fairness — long before he had done anything on the field to earn their undying devotion as an athlete. He said later that their boisterous support at home in Delorimier Stadium gave him the breathing space he needed to become a star. Robinson quite literally spent the rest of his life thanking Montrealers for their support in 1946 and eagerly accepted every opportunity to return to the city for a victory lap visit with his old friends.
A few years ago I started working on a book, Royal Treatment: Jackie Robinson, Montreal, and the Breaking of Baseball's Color Barrier (University of Nebraska Press, 2026), for two main reasons. I was never looking to emigrate as university started to wind down back in 2009, but I ended up finding the academic work opportunities I wanted in the United States rather than at home in Canada. It feels profoundly weird travelling on an American passport these days and I can assure you that my heart and soul were with the red and white, not the red, white, and blue, during the Olympics, but I have made my peace with being a dualie Canadian expat in the United States. As this project began, I approached telling the story about Montreal’s relationship with Jackie Robinson as a means of letting American readers in on our values, expressed through baseball fandom. At the same time, I also thought that Canadian readers would enjoy going into much more depth on a topic of which they may be superficially aware of thanks to annual Jackie Robinson Day news articles that briefly mention his time in Montreal. For both, I wanted to advance the argument that unique social and cultural factors in Canada that had absolutely nothing to do with baseball helped make the Great Experiment work. Feelings of second-class citizenship in Canada made many Quebeckers instinctively gravitate towards Robinson as a fellow underdog and the Prohibition Era jazz boom shook up ideas about the contributions Black entertainers made to the city’s cultural life. This backdrop made Montrealers the most receptive potential audience for the Great Experiment decades before Rickey dared to try it.
Back in the beginning, Jackie Robinson was unveiled to the baseball world on October 23, 1945, but not by Branch Rickey and not in Brooklyn. The press conference to announce his signing was run by a group of francophone Québécois executives who ran the AAA Royals and it unfolded in Montreal. Club president Hector Racine had promised the city’s sportswriters “the biggest baseball story to ever hit this town,” which temporarily got hearts fluttering over rumours that Babe Ruth was about to take over as the Royals manager or, better still, that the Royals’ strong gate numbers had earned them a promotion to the big leagues. No one had any inkling that the Royals were about to become the vanguard in a direct assault on a nearly-airtight segregation policy that had been in place in professional baseball since members of the Chicago White Stockings led by Hall of Fame racist Cap Anson banded together to ban Black players in 1884.
The Montreal press corps was, for the most part, underwhelmed during its first meeting with Robinson, but not for anything he did or said or general prejudice. Few were thinking about minor league baseball the following spring just a few days away from puck drop on another great season from the Stanley Cup champion Canadiens. At the same time, there really wasn’t anything revolutionary to Quebeckers about the prospect of a Black man joining a predominantly White professional baseball team. As Christian Trudeau’s research shows, baseball in Quebec had integrated at least two and a half decades before Robinson showed up in Montreal and even semi-professional teams in small outlying towns like Granby and Sorel had Black players in the 1930s. As with prohibition, Quebec had already said, “non, merci” to the so-called gentlemen’s agreement.
Two things happened in late March and early April 1946 to shake Montrealers out of their inattention to the Great Experiment. First, the Habs put the Bruins in a 3-0 Stanley Cup Final chokehold with a road win on April 4, meaning that Montreal sports fans could exhale and start thinking about what was coming next after the NHL season wrapped. Second, sportswriters started spilling more ink on Royals spring training, sharing with their readers accounts of how Robinson (and Black teammate John Wright) had been barred from the team hotel on racial grounds and of increasingly frequent Jim Crow-induced game cancellations. Branch Rickey had been assured that local officials would temporarily suspend Jim Crow and allow Robinson to play for the sake of maintaining friendly relations with the Dodgers organization, but he was willing to take a play it by ear approach if there was trouble. Robinson would travel with the team, but if locals refused to allow him onto the field, the organization would comply. To Rickey, spring training was an endurance test, a speed bump on the path to bigger things. The Dodgers would do their best to get Robinson enough reps in games, but if they had to run intersquad scrimmages on the fly to make it happen that would have to do. Pragmatic or cowardly, the result was that five Royals games over the crucial final week of spring training were either boycotted or cancelled.
Branch Rickey was disappointed, but restrained. Royals management, by contrast, was loud and angry about how Floridians had treated their new player. Hector Racine bellowed, “it will be all or nothing with the Montreal club. Jackie Robinson and John Wright come with the club or there’s no game.” Sportswriters for Le Soleil and Le Droit got their readers up to speed on the Robinson situation and took pride in Racine’s principled decision to stand up to bigots. Charles Daoust of Le Droit wrote, “we congratulate Royals management for having canceled their exhibition game in Jacksonville tomorrow against the Jersey City Little Giants... Montrealers will not stomach this gesture of intolerance.” On the cusp of the season opener, Le Droit put it in aspirational, revolutionary terms: “French Canada, which has always been the asylum of the oppressed..., [has] the chance in 1946 to break the links of ethnic intolerance. In baseball, Montreal will destroy color bias.”
Tonally, coverage of Robinson’s first camp was completely different in the Quebec papers relative to American ones. As spring training began to wind down, American sportswriters highlighted Robinson’s visible struggles on the field without contextualizing them as the result of too much positional rotation around the diamond, a nagging injury to his throwing arm, and the extreme stress of having to work within the constraints of unjust Florida segregation laws. The implication was clear: this Black player, and Black players in general, just couldn’t cut it in a White man’s league.
By contrast, Quebec’s French-language papers tended to report instead on how Robinson was improving on a daily basis to the point where it was becoming easier to see him as a major contributor at the top of the Royals lineup. Quebec-based and Canadian papers also frequently ran photos of Robinson in their Royals spring training updates, whereas their major American counterparts did not for fear of offending racist elements within their readership. In general, Robinson coverage in Canadian papers was starting to tilt more toward that of the Black American press—a genuine enthusiasm for the Great Experiment—and away from that of mainstream American papers that observed neutrally with racially-coded language or expressed skepticism. Well before the club came north for its home opener, the Montreal press corps was not so subtly encouraging Royals fans to find a special place in their hearts for Robinson.
As the weather began to turn in early 1946, baseball fans were most excited about all of the stars who were returning from military service, among them Ted Williams of the Red Sox, Bob Feller of Cleveland, and Stan Musial of the Cardinals. Still, the biggest storyline of the year pitted Jackie Robinson and Montreal against a change-averse world and the racist status quo.
Royals fans had to endure an agonizing wait for their first chance to see their new hero play. Robinson debuted as a Royal on the road in front of a packed house in Roosevelt Stadium in Jersey City on April 18. His debut was explosive and, for Montrealers, powerfully FOMO-inducing. Robinson picked up 4 hits, including a three-run home run down the left-field line and a drag-bunt single; stole 2 bases; collected 4 RBI; and scored 4 runs, one of which came when he used his disruptive presence on the bases to force the opposing pitcher to balk him in from third. His Royals trounced Jersey City, 14–1; a loud statement had been made to all of the doubters. Montrealers were firmly behind Robinson as a change agent before he moved to town, but it would be too good to be true if he also turned out to be a crackerjack ballplayer. Everybody who mattered in Montreal turned out for the home opener; there was so much excitement about Jackie Robinson that hardly anyone in the park even noticed that among the crowd there was Maurice “Rocket” Richard, fresh off a Stanley Cup win, cheering his lungs out with all the other Royals fans.
Out on the road there were knuckle-dragging racists and jackasses among the Royals’ International League opponents and their fan bases (Baltimore, Buffalo, and Rochester were particularly rough), but at home Robinson enjoyed the unwavering support of a vocal collective of progressives that cut across everyone single one of Montreal’s fraught linguistic, sectarian, and racial divides. He excelled as the key cog in a high OBP and stolen-base driven offense that pummeled International League opponents all season long. Robinson should clearly have been the MVP of the International League in 1946. He put up a .349 average, five points clear of the two next best hitters, and his .468 on-base average led the league by a huge margin. He was one of the most difficult hitters in the league to strike out and he stole 40 bases, second only to his teammate Marvin “Rabbit” Rackley and 10 clear of the next best thief. The vote instead went to a conventional candidate, plodding Baltimore Orioles first baseman Eddie Robinson, author of a fine .318.405/.578 season with 34 home runs and 123 RBI. Jackie Robinson had the last laugh, though; his Royals had basically wrapped up the International League pennant race by early August and charged into the playoffs with a franchise best 100-54 record.
The Royals bested all International League opponents, including a very good Yogi Berra-led Newark Bears squad, to take the Governors’ Cup and earn a fascinating matchup with the Louisville Colonels in the Junior World Series for the biggest prize in all of minor league baseball. Louisville was the top farm club for the AL pennant-winning Boston Red Sox and the team was overloaded with major league quality pitching (including Al Widmar, a former Blue Jays coach/executive the old timers here will remember). If anyone could slow down the Royals’ vaunted lineup, it was the Colonels. Louisville also played in a home park so cavernous it bordered on ridiculous, meaning that defense and baserunning were likely to become decisive factors.
You can read all about the details of that series in Royal Treatment, or, if your French is good, in Marcel Dugas’ excellent Jackie Robinson, un été à Montréal (Hurtubise: 2019). The good guys not only won, but they clinched at home in front of the Royals faithful.
October 4, 1946 is a baseball date that means little to anyone, but I would argue that it matters more than the one you do know, April 15, 1947. The Royals had won the Junior World Series, Robinson led the way, and everyone in the crowd understood that they had just seen one of the most special players in the history of the game put on a Montreal uniform for the last time. The city’s baseball fans desperately thronged into the streets hoping for one last look at their hero before he left town. Sam Maltin reported from the scene: Down the street he went, chased by five hundred fans. People opened windows and came pouring out of their houses to see what the commotion was about. For three blocks they chased him until a car drew up and someone shouted: ‘Jump in Jackie!’ That he did, and sat down–plunk in a lady’s lap… It was probably the only day in history that a black man ran from a white mob with love instead of lynching on its mind.
This heartwarming, spontaneous outburst of emotion from Royals fans was both entirely predictable and a complete vindication for all those who had been arguing for years in favor of integrating baseball. Despite the delayed escape from the ballpark, Robinson made his flight to Detroit after all. Alone, up in the sky, he finally had a moment to reflect. “As my plane roared skyward and the lights of Montreal twinkled and winked in the distance,” he wrote, “I took one last look at this great city where I had found so much happiness. ‘I don’t care if I never get to the Majors,’ I told myself. ‘This is the city for me. This is paradise.’”
Once he got his feet under him as an established big leaguer, Robinson started speaking publicly in a manner that was direct, bordering on blunt. He did not pull punches, nor did he forgive old grudges, and he was often pessimistic about his countrymen. He chided baseball for being so slow to hire Black coaches in his last public appearance in a pregame ceremony before game two of the 1972 World Series at Riverfront Stadium in Cincinnati. He finished writing his autobiography, I Never Had it Made, the year he died, wrapping up on an incredibly downcast note as he reflected on his first appearance in a World Series game. “As I write this twenty years later,” he wrote, “I cannot stand and sing the anthem. I cannot salute the flag; I know that I am a black man in a white world.”
For all of success and public acclaim, it would not be unfair to say that Robinson carried much bitterness to the grave. This made his frequent praise for Montreal and Montrealers stand out all the more as a genuine expression of gratitude. Whether it was a return visit to sign the city’s Golden Book at City Hall in the late 1950s, for a football game or a visit to Expo 67 in the 1960s, or a quick turn at the mic in the Expos booth in the early 1970s, his stories were always the same: he and Rachel found in Montreal a good hearted landlady, wonderful neighbours, and public adulation every time they walked down the street. The unspoken part was that basic Canadian/Québécois/Montréalais decency stood out so much given the contrast with home soil treatment back in the United States. This is why he loved Montrealers just as much as they loved him, prompting him to repeatedly thank them for having been so good to him and Rachel during that magical 1946 season.
After Jackie passed in 1972, Rachel took every invitation from the Expos to speak in Montreal about his legacy. She was honoured on the field at the All-Star Game in 1982 and again later in the decade at the unveiling of the Jackie Robinson statue now located in front of Olympic Stadium. When she grew too old to travel, their daughter, Sharon, kept up the relationship, travelling to Montreal when the US Consulate unveiled an historic plaque at the Robinsons one-time apartment in Villeray back in 2012. Montreal clearly has a place in all of their hearts.
Royal Treatment is as much a book about Montreal values as it is Jackie Robinson and I was compelled to wrap it up by showing how the city has embraced its connection to him through street art, statuary, and public history as a means of asserting its own progressive bona fides to the world. Visitors to Montreal like you and I today could make a delightful spring or summer trip to all of the Robinson pilgrimage sites like the old home of the Royals at Delorimier, the Robinsons’ former apartment on de Gaspé Avenue, and the iconic Olympic Stadium statue along with numerous murals scattered throughout the city, stopping when peckish for poutine or a smoked meat sandwich washed down with a glass of something cold from McAuslan Brewing or Unibroue. People like us will come looking for traces of him, but to many Montrealers Jackie Robinson has never really left.
2 comments
https://www.battersbox.ca/article.php?story=20260319234345316