Beyond the First Round - Hitters

Wednesday, May 31 2006 @ 11:00 AM EDT

Contributed by: Pistol

Last year's edition of this article found two players that were selected by the Jays.

Same rules as last week with the pitchers - since the Jays pick at #120 I'm only going to look at players who are ranked #120 or higher at Baseball America.

Cole Gillespie, OF, Oregon St, 6-1, 200, RH
BA Rank - 122

Year ABs Ave OBP SLG K/BB K%
2006 189 0.370 0.492 0.683 0.7 11.3%
2005 94 0.319 0.455 0.362 0.6 10.8%
2004 62 0.290 0.371 0.500 1.8 20.0%

Gillespie is a versitlie player who's played all three OF positions and both corner infield spots. He's improved his power considerably this year. I suspect his friends call him Dizzy, although thinking about it more I suspect his friends are too young to call him that.

Cyle Hankerd, OF, USC, 6-2, 205, RH
BA Rank - 129

Year ABs Ave OBP SLG K/BB K%
2006 230 0.383 0.469 0.587 1.4 14.4%
2005 218 0.298 0.378 0.404 1.8 16.9%
2004 141 0.333 0.443 0.411 1.6 22.7%

Another player who improved considerably this year, particularly his power. Note that USC plays one of the toughest schedules.

Jordan Newton, C, Western Kentucky, 6-0, 190, RH
BA Rank - 149

Year ABs Ave OBP SLG K/BB K%
2006 176 0.324 0.468 0.699 1.0 18.9%
2005 216 0.329 0.422 0.620 1.6 18.6%
2004 197 0.325 0.436 0.492 1.6 17.2%

He strikes out a lot, but when he hits it it goes a long way - to do it at catcher is nice to have. The average has remained the same for the most part with the power improving each year. Newton also takes a fair share of walks.

Matt McBride, C, Lehigh, 6-3, 205, RH
BA Rank - 154

Year ABs Ave OBP SLG K/BB K%
2006 204 0.417 0.464 0.667 0.7 6.1%
2005 182 0.258 0.312 0.385 1.5 8.0%
2004 172 0.366 0.415 0.547 1.4 10.1%

If you like catchers with a good average, good power, good speed (21 steals) who don't strike out you might like this guy. Plus, the first line of his BA scouting report is "McBride's strength has always been his catch-and-throw skills". Sounds like someone who should be a lot higher than #154.

Shane Robinson, OF, Florida St, 5-9, 165, RH
BA Rank - 169

Year ABs Ave OBP SLG K/BB K%
2006 257 0.350 0.430 0.490 0.7 7.7%
2005 286 0.427 0.532 0.605 0.5 7.9%
2004 275 0.280 0.358 0.371 1.5 11.3%

Robinson had a great 2005 but hasn't followed it up in 2006. He's a small, quick, leadoff type, but he might be too small to be an everyday player. His ISO Slg is just .140 this year which isn't a good sign. He's probably a lot of fun to watch though.

Tyler Colvin, OF, Clemson, 6-3, 190, LH
BA Rank - 170

Year ABs Ave OBP SLG K/BB K%

2006

247

0.360

0.426

0.632

1.5 13.8%
2005 258 0.283 0.323 0.442 2.2 11.3%
2004 128 0.289 0.350 0.414 1.5 11.4%

Like most juniors he's improved considerably this year. He's not considered to be strong in any one area, but isn't considered weak in any area either.

Whit Robbins, 1B/3B, Georgia Tech, 6-1, 208, LH
BA Rank - 177

Year ABs Ave OBP SLG K/BB K%
2006 221 0.367 0.480 0.620 0.8 12.1%
2005 162 0.265 0.411 0.444 0.5 10.2%
2004 144 0.313 0.421 0.438 0.7 11.5%

Another improved junior. Robbins held up well against the North Carolina duo of Miller and Bard, hitting a homerun off of Bard this spring.

Chad Huffman, 1B/2B, TCU, 6-1, 206, RH
BA Rank - 178

Year ABs Ave OBP SLG K/BB K%
2006 196 0.388 0.504 0.765 0.8 11.9%
2005 241 0.353 0.437 0.573 1.0 9.7%
2004 253 0.383 0.477 0.577 1.2 9.4%

You don't see too many 1B/2B combos do you? Well, outside of softball that is. Huffman's defensive position is the real question. Perhaps third, the OF, or maybe just DH. Regardless of the position he can hit. He continually had a high average and boosted his slugging over .750 with a .377 ISO. And he did that with a reasonable strikeout rate in a slight pitcher's park against decent competition. I like him the most of any player on this list. In my (primitive) adjustments for schedule and park Huffman comes out at #3 overall among hitters.

For what it's worth, where these players rank in my adjusted college stats:

Gillespie - 6
Hankerd - 19
Newton - 42
McBride - 85
Robinson - 340
Colvin - 124
Robbins - 34
Huffman - 3

Interestingly, last year Brian Pettway was #2 and Ryan Patterson was #4.

On Monday I'll look at who's likely to be gone, who'll be available and who the Jays might be likely to select when their pick comes up in round 1.

9 comments



https://www.battersbox.ca/article.php?story=20060530124614322