Which Evans belongs in the Hall of Fame?
| Darrell |  12 (13.64%) |
| Dwight | 11 (12.50%) |
| Both | 18 (20.45%) |
| Neither | 47 (53.41%) |
88 votes | 3 featured comments
Both, eventually. There are other more worthy players who need to be enshrined first, and Darrell should go in probably well before Dewey, but I think it would be fair overall if both made it one day.
Interestingly enough, there are only 3 players in the top 30 for all
time Walks who aren't in the HOF/ineligable (playing or Pete Rose'd).
Those 3 are Darryl Evans, Dwight Evans and Eddie Yost.
The rest are basically locks for the Hall when they become eligable (Henderson, Bonds, Thomas...), with maybe Raffi being left out.
Those 3 are Darryl Evans, Dwight Evans and Eddie Yost.
The rest are basically locks for the Hall when they become eligable (Henderson, Bonds, Thomas...), with maybe Raffi being left out.
I don't think either will get in, even eventually like Bruce says.
However, I DO think both BELONG in the HOF. And half of you are saying "neither"? Explain!