Andy Pettitte is coming back to the Bronx. Maybe it's too early to ask, but with 201 wins and 14 more in the post-season ... Andy Pettitte, Hall of Famer?
| Yes |  0 (0.00%) |
| No | 0 (0.00%) |
| He'll get in but shouldn't | 0 (0.00%) |
| He won't get in but should | 0 (0.00%) |
| Too soon to tell | 0 (0.00%) |
0 votes | 2 featured comments
I said 'none' but if I had to call it, I'd go with Pettitte just because of the WS titles, knowing how to win, etc. Stuff I'd not vote him in for, but I could easily see the voters doing so.
I agree with John. In my mind, Colon and Brown have no chance, but choosing between Mussina and Pettitte was tough. In the end, I think the voters look at titles, and while neither has won a Cy Young, Pettitte did come in 2nd in 96, although I suspect Mussina has more top-10 finishes. Still, top ten finishes are a red herring in my mind. I mean, the only reason I remember Pettitte's 2nd-place result was because Hentgen beat him. Who remembers who finished 7th in any given year?