Toronto at Detroit, July 24-27

Thursday, July 24 2025 @ 03:50 PM EDT

Contributed by: Magpie

Road trip! Beginning with the annual pilgrimage to Comerica Park. Not the hooly blisful martir for to seke, but rather to tangle with a Tiger or two. Or twenty-six.

The Tigers, until this very week, had sported the best record in the entire American League, a development I don't recall anyone forecasting. I recall myself noting that while their awful performances in recent years had landed them some very tasty places in the amateur draft, they didn't seem to be reaping the usual rewards. The Tigers got the first pick in the amateur draft twice in a three year period - (in half a century, the Blue Jays have never picked first overall) - they ended up with Casey Mize in 2018 and Spencer Torkelson in 2020. They missed out on Adley Rutschmann and Bobby Witt Jr the year in between. After a promising rookie year, Mize basically lost two full seasons to injury, and Torkelson spent three years looking like A Flop.

Mize has made it back into the rotation, and is having himself a fine season (9-4, 3.40.) He gives up lots of hits, and he doesn't strike out a whole lot of guys, but he doesn't walk a lot of hitters and generally keeps the ball in the yard. In other words, he's a younger version of Chris Bassitt.

As for Torkelson, after his disappointing 2024 season, he looks quite likely to duplicate his 2023 season numbers - but just a little better. There are incremental improvements - he's hitting a few more doubles, which has given his Slugging a bit of a boost, and he's drawing a few more walks to lift his OnBase a little. He's a 30-35 HR guy who's gone from .233/.313/.446 to .239/.339/.487 - and of course, offense in the AL is down a little from what it was in 2023, which makes what he's done more useful.

Of course, when you get a player as good as Tarik Skubal in the ninth round, you shouldn't be allowed to complain too much. The Blue Jays have been extremely good at missing Skubal's turn in the rotation. They haven't faced him since July 2023. On that occasion, Skubal was making just his second start of the season after returning from flexor tendon surgery, and the Tigers were still building him up. He was, at that point, just on the verge of becoming Tarik Skubal. On this occasion, he was pulled after four shutout innings and 63 pitches. (The Jays would come back to win in ten.) His one other appearance against the Jays came back in June 2022 - the Jays got to him for four runs in the fourth inning, keyed by Guerrero's two run homer, and tagged him with the L, behind Ross Stripling's six innings of one-hit shutout..

Like John Schneider, A.J. Hinch has taken merry advantage of the fact that he's got some very moveable pieces on his roster. Javier Baez has started more games (31) at shortstop than anywhere else, but he's seen plenty of action in centre field (28 starts) and third base (16 starts) as well. Zach McKinstry is as close as Hinch has to a regular third baseman (47 starts), but you can also see him in right field (28 starts), left field (9 starts), or shortstop (9 starts) as well. This is helpful, because the two men usually in the lineup at shortstop (Trey Sweeney) and centre field (Parker Meadows) don't hit much at all. But everybody else does and has. Only two AL teams have scored more runs.

As everyone knows, the Blue Jays are world-beaters and Yankee Killers at home in their dome. On the road, they're not so great. Basically, the offense falls off a cliff. They've scored 5.35 Runs per Game at the RC, and just 3.85 Runs per Game on the road. Clearly a Data Table of the Home/Road splits will be called for at some point. Gosh, who will provide such a thing?

The Blue Jays have hit .274/.346/.454 in their 54 home games - that's a pretty nice OPS of .800, and the highest scoring team in baseball (Yankees, damn Yankees) has a collective OPS of .787. So, yeah, the Jays have been swinging it really well at home. 

But when they get south of the border, then comes the crash - .246/.317/.357, which is an OPS of .674, and just a handful of teams have done worse. So let's look at the individuals involved and see who's taken the Biggest Fall. 

And because I have mighty Excel skills and I don't mind showing off, I have pro-rated all individual figures to that of a 162 game schedule (so they resemble normal season numbers.) I have done this by the clever tactic of multiplying all home numbers by 3 and all road numbers by 3.375. Math skillz, I haz them. 

At home, this is an impressive lineup.

              G   PA   AB   R    H   2B 3B  HR  RBI  SB CS   BB   SO  BAVG   OBP   SLG    OPS
                                                                    
Guerrero    159  711  594  102  168  42  0  27  108  3  6  105  114  .283  .392  .490    .882
Bichette    153  684  651   93  204  54  3  33  111  12  6  27  105  .313  .346  .558    .904
Springer    153  618  510  117  156  27  0  33  87  15  0  90  117  .306  .411  .553    .964
Clement    162  579  540   69  153  30  3  9  60  0  3  18  48  .283  .309  .400    .709
Kirk    135  540  480   45  135  18  0  12  75  0  0  51  51  .281  .350  .394    .744
Barger    132  480  438   69  126  30  0  27  78  6  3  36  102  .288  .346  .541    .887
Gimenez    93  360  324   48  75  9  0  12  39  12  3  18  48  .231  .308  .370    .679
Lukes    120  360  306   54  78  12  0  6  60  0  3  39  36  .255  .342  .353    .695
Santander    81  336  297   30  57  12  0  9  33  0  0  36  84  .192  .277  .323    .600
Straw    138  303  279   63  66  24  0  3  24  12  0  21  42  .237  .290  .355    .645
Schneider    66  189  150   36  42  9  0  9  27  0  3  33  45  .280  .429  .520    .949
Varsho    45  177  162   36  39  9  3  18  45  3  0  12  51  .241  .288  .667    .955
Wagner    54  171  150   27  51  18  0  0  12  0  0  18  33  .340  .411  .460    .871
Roden    63  156  132   27  30  6  3  3  15  0  0  9  33  .227  .308  .386    .694
Heineman    54  150  129   27  48  15  0  6  36  3  0  9  30  .372  .408  .628   1.036
Clase    42  135  117   15   30  3  0  3  12  9  0  15  30  .256  .356  .359    .715

But then, this happens.

             G    PA   AB    R   H   2B 3B  HR  RBI  SB CS   BB   SO  BAVG   OBP   SLG    OPS
                                                                    
Bichette    162  732  675   57  165  37  0   7   74   0  3   47  125  .245  .295  .330    .625
Guerrero    159  685  587  101  169  20  0  14   47  14  0   84  81  .287  .389  .391   .780
Springer    152  597  513   71  132  27  3  20   88  24  0   64  111  .257  .337  .441   .778
Clement    155  591  533   81  149  34  0  3   24  10  7   47  64  .278  .331  .361   .692
Kirk    138  540  493   41  162  20  0  10   71   0  0   41  54  .329  .375  .432   .807
Barger    115  432  408   61  105  41  0  17   61   3  0   24  122  .256  .297  .479   .776
Gimenez    101  398  348   34  71  14  0  3   34  20  0   34  78  .204  .291  .272   .562
Lukes    122  388  327   34   88  10  0  10   44   3  3   47  57  .268  .366  .392   .758
Straw    128  338  300   34   74  7  0  0   30  10  3   14  51  .247  .284  .270   .554
Santander    78  327  287   14   47  3  0  10   24   0  0   41  91  .165  .268  .282   .550
Clase    68  226  206   17   37  7  0  3   17   0  3   17  61  .180  .242  .262   .505
Roden    71  199  179   10   34  10  0  0   10   0  3   14  44  .189  .254  .245   .500
Wagner    54  182  152   10   20  3  0  0    7   3  0   24  41  .133  .278  .156   .433
Heineman    57  162  142   34   44  3  0  3   14   3  0   10  30  .310  .383  .405   .788
Varsho    30  138  128    7   20  7  0  7   17   0  0    3  47  .158  .171  .368   .539
Schneider    54  135  111   14   14  0  0  7   10   0  0   24  47  .121  .275  .303   .578

Two things leap out at me, and having ducked out of their path, I will tell you what they are.

First, the power just dries up. The number of home runs falls almost in half, and those 30 or so Big Flys turning into Fly Outs accounts for a sizeable chunk of the drop in BAVG, OnBase, and Slugging (roughly two thirds of it, I reckon.)

One hitter in particular has really struggled away from home. I mean, most of them aren't hitting nearly as well, but Bo Bichette really stands out: I mean, yikes! - .313/.346/.558 at home and .245/.295/.330 on the road? His OPS drops 279 points, from .904 to .625 (Wagner, Varsho, and Schneider have even bigger drop offs on the road, but their samples are pretty tiny, just 40-54 road plate appearances.)

Guerrero, Springer, and Barger are still solid hitters on the road, although their collective power shortage is not good. Kirk and Lukes have actually hit a little bit better away from home, and Ernie Clement doesn't care where the games are played. Bichette is the biggest culprit, and here's the thing - I'm pretty sure it's a fluke. Just One of Those Things. Coming into this season, Bo Bichette had about the smallest Home/Road split of anyone on the team. He's actually been a better hitter on the road in each of the last three seasons. Go figure.

Matchups

Thu 24 July - Lauer (5-2, 2.80) vs Olson (4-3, 2.71)
Fri 25 July - Berrios (6-4, 3.87) vs Montero (4-2, 4.28)
Sat 26 July - Gausman (7-7, 4.01) vs Skubal (10-3, 2.19)
Sun 27 July - Scherzer (1-0, 5.14) vs Flaherty (5-10, 4.77)

324 comments



https://www.battersbox.ca/article.php?story=20250724143926363