Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine
In honor of yesterday's 133rd running of the Kentucky Derby, let's see if we can have the "Sweet Sense" to piece together a Hall of (Place) Names team made up entirely of MLB alumni who were born in the Bluegrass State.

There have been 260 such men so far -- frankly, more than I thought there would be ...

... and once you get past a tough start in finding a manger and a catcher, this squad is actually pretty good! Though you do have to wonder -- will our backup shortstop and righty long reliever be able to co-exist as teammates?

Only three Kentucky-born men have managed in the big leagues, and two of those actually made the active roster; given that their combined mark as MLB skippers was just 106-178, a .373 winning percentage, we'll just appoint all three to a "college of coaches" staff and see what happens ...

The starting catcher is a name that will be familiar to Blue Jay fans of The Early Years, but his career .215 batting average over nearly two decades in the big leagues means he will hit ninth, certainly ... And our backup backstop if a guy who mostly played the OF but who moved around enough to earn super-utility status on this team ...

Make your own joke about Kentucky's close families, I guess, but nearly half of the players on the roster had close relatives who were also big league ballplayers -- including the patriarch of one of the great game's three-generation families in this team's starting LF ...

The Hall of Famers on this team are all of the "Maybe they weren't the best selection on statistical merit" category, in Reese, Combs and Bunning ... The pitching, even though the bullpen lacks a true closer, is really this team's strength ... Hey, a group of five guys who didn't even make the roster includes the reigning NL Cy Young Award winner and four others who each posted at least one 25-win season ...

Anyway, enough of the four-corners offense -- let's drive to the hoop, Kentucky-style, aiming for the ballpark affectionately nicknamed "My Old Kentucky Home" and meet ...

** indicates Hall of Famer
* indicates All-Star

Eddie Haas (50-71)
Fred Pfeffer (42-56)
Jimmy Wolf (14-51)

C Phil Roof (.215, 43 homers, 1961-77)
1B Dan McGann (.284, 1896-1908)
2B Dan Uggla* (.282 as 2006 rookie All-Star)
SS Pee Wee Reese** (2170 hits, 10-time All-Star)
3B Travis Fryman* (.274, 223 homers, 1990-2002)
LF Gus Bell* (.281, 206 homers)
CF Earle Combs** (.325, 1924-35)
RF Jay Buhner* (310 homers in 15 years)
DH Pete Browning (OF hit .341, 1882-94; .402 in 1887)

OF/IF/C Jimmy Wolf (.290, 1882-92)
SS Ray Chapman (.278, 1912-20)
IF/UTIL Fred Pfeffer (.255, 1882-97; 25 homers in 1884)
OF Mike Greenwell* (.303, 130 homers, 1985-96)
OF George Harper (.303, 1916-29)
OF Bobby Veach (.310, 2063 hits, 1912-25)

RHSP Jim Bunning** (224-184)
LHSP Jesse Tannehill (197-116; six-time 20-game winner)
RHSP Gus Weyhing (264-232, 1887-1901)
LHSP Don Gullett (109-50, 1970-78)
RHSP Paul Derringer* (223-212)


CL-RH Joe Heving (76-48, 63 saves, 1930-45)
LH-SET Steve Hamilton (40-31, 42 saves in 12 years)
RH-SET Don Robinson (109-106, 57 saves)
LH-LONG Woodie Fryman* (141-155, 58 saves)
RH-LONG Carl Mays (207-126)

RHSP Howie Camnitz (133-106; 25-6 in 1909)
RHSP Red Ehret (139-167, 1888-98, 25-14 in 1890)
RHSP Brandon Webb* (2006 NL Cy Young)
RHSP Johnny Morrison (103-80, 23 saves; 25-13 in 1923)
RHSP Scott Stratton (97-114; 34-14 in 1890)
1B/OF Todd Benzinger (.257 in 9 years)
2B Denny Doyle (.250, 1970-77)
OF Austin Kearns (.265, 79 homers through 2006)
IF Doug Flynn (.238, 1975-85)

So, Bauxites, who's missing? Any way we can make this team even more of a, well, "Wildcat" squad? ...

Rundown for the Roses? | 8 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
FanfromTheIsland - Sunday, May 06 2007 @ 10:38 AM EDT (#167339) #

  I guess you chose you chose the rotation by the best career W-L records, because Brandon Webb being cut from any rotation is something I wouldn't expect...

Maybe it's because I'm young, but why wouldn't Ray Chapman and Carl Mays be able to play as teammates?

Magpie - Sunday, May 06 2007 @ 10:41 AM EDT (#167340) #
Ray Chapman was killed by a pitch. Carl Mays threw it.

You have the current senator from Kentucky in the rotation - could there be some sort of honorary role for the two time governor who was also the second commissioner of baseball.

Magpie - Sunday, May 06 2007 @ 10:47 AM EDT (#167342) #
And, Fanfrom theIsland, if you've got some time on your hands this pleasant Sunday, the sad tale of Mays and Chapman (along with all sorts of other wild and wacky events, like the emergence of Babe Ruth and the breaking of the Black Sox scandal)  is all told at somewhat excessive length in one of those Extreme Epics I produce from time to time.

Not to toot my own horn or anything, but The Year in Review: 1920 is probably my personal favourite of everything I've ever written for this site.

Okay, okay. Toot toot!

actionjackson - Sunday, May 06 2007 @ 01:06 PM EDT (#167344) #
Is Scott "Churchill" Downs good enough to make the final cuts roster as a relief pitcher or does he have a ways to go yet? Maybe you could stick him in the minors if he's not good enough. Certainly his last name should help in the Bluegrass State, not to mention my nickname for him.  ;)
FanfromTheIsland - Monday, May 07 2007 @ 04:21 PM EDT (#167398) #

  ""  was all I could think about when I read that. I assume it was a fastball straight to the head, or Ray Chapman had an open stance and it hit... you know...

  My apologies, I missed (D' oh!) your Extreme Epic. And for some reason the link to TYIB: 1920 isn't working. "The page cannot be displayed" keeps popping up in my face.

Mike Green - Monday, May 07 2007 @ 04:46 PM EDT (#167400) #
Webb has a career ERA+ of 138. Heckuva pitcher.  I'd rather have him on the club than Don Robinson (although Robinson could hit, and might be useful as an emergency pinch-hitter).
Mike Green - Monday, May 07 2007 @ 04:48 PM EDT (#167401) #
Oh yeah, and Veach was a better hitter than Bell.
Mick Doherty - Monday, May 07 2007 @ 05:26 PM EDT (#167404) #

I went with Bell over Veach in the starting lineup because there is scarce little power in that lineup and Gus is far more of a longball threat than little Bobby I think.

I think Robinson gets the bullpen spot because I tend to not stuff the bullpen with guys who didn't make the rotation and Robinson actually worked out of the bullpen whereas Webb does not ... so you have to choose, Webb or Mays in the bullpen as the RH long man? Webb may get there, but I don't think he bumps Carl's 200+ wins yet.

Happy to hear counterpoints, of course.

Rundown for the Roses? | 8 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.