Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine
Day 2 of the MLB Draft begins at 11:30 am Eastern Time this morning with rounds 4-20 on MLB.com. The Jays are picking 112th to start the day. You can follow the Jays draft selections right here.


Image from Dallas Baptist.

Round 4 - 112th overall. RHP Micah Bucknam, Dallas Baptist. Bats Right, Throws Right. 6-foot-1, 212 pounds. Born August 26, 2003. Slot Value $680,800.

MLB.com Scouting Report - One of the best Canadian prospects in the 2022 Draft, Bucknam turned down the Blue Jays as a 16th-rounder to attend Louisiana State. He worked just 16 innings in two seasons in Baton Rouge because of command issues, enjoying more success in two summers in the Cape Cod League before transferring to Dallas Baptist. He became the Patriots' No. 1 starter and has some of the best feel for spin in the college ranks. Bucknam's tight 85-88 mph slider can reach 91, features high spin rates and is a legitimate wipeout pitch, while his low-80s curveball has more depth and is nearly as effective. His fastball stands out more for its velocity, usually ranging from 92-96 mph, than its life or ability to miss bats. He achieves some fade with his upper-80s changeup, though it's too firm and he struggles to land it for strikes. Bucknam has a strong 6-foot-1 frame and has improved his control as a junior, though he still gets into trouble when he catches too much of the plate. To succeed as a starter at the next level, he'll have to improve his fastball command and refine his changeup. If not, he could thrive as a reliever who relies heavily on his breaking pitches. Video

Baseball America Scouting Report - Bucknam was born in New Zealand and grew up in Canada, where he became a well-known high school prospect and was drafted by the Blue Jays in the 16th round in 2021. He instead enrolled at LSU, where he made eight relief appearances in each of his first two seasons before transferring to Dallas Baptist for the 2025 season. A 6-foot-1, 210-pound righthander, Bucknam moved into a starting role with DBU and found success, going 6-2, 4.62 with a 29.4% strikeout rate and a 9.2% walk rate. Bucknam works with a true four-pitch mix. His 93-94 mph four-seam fastball can touch 96 and now shows more carry with less run than earlier in his amateur career. He also throws a hard slider in the upper 80s, a slower, bigger curveball in the low 80s and an upper-80s changeup with plenty of armside fade. It’s a lively arsenal that produced plenty of whiffs both in and out of the zone. Both his slider and curveball generated miss rates above 45% in 2025. Bucknam’s control is generally solid, and he has shortened his arm path since his freshman year, though evaluators still have concerns about whether his command and feel for his secondaries will ultimately push him to a relief role. His improvements in 2025 should at least give him a better chance to stick on a starter track.

Twitter Reaction

@baseballcanada Congrats to @BaseballCANJNT alum RHP Micah Bucknam (Abbotsford, BC), selected by the @BlueJays in the fourth round, 112th overall in the 2025 #MLBDraft!

@MattPowers31 Micah Bucknam off the board to Jays. He is a guy the Braves were really looking at.

@JoeDoyleMiLB Quite like this pick for the Blue Jays. Micah Bucknam has velocity and has one of the better sliders in the Draft.

@Tyson_MLB Micah Bucknam comes full circle for the #BlueJays. Increased his draft ranking and won a College World Series ring with LSU. Not too shabby.


Image from @piasentintim

Round 5 - 143rd overall. 3B Tim Piasentin, Foothills Composite High School, Okotoks, Alberta. Bats Left, Throws Right. 6-foot-3, 200 pounds. Born March 25, 2007. Slot Value $503,800.

MLB.com Scouting Report - The Canadian province of Alberta has produced just four big leaguers, a quartet of right-handed pitchers led by Michael Soroka. A year ago, Nathan Flewelling represented the western region as a big, strong left-handed high school hitter whom the Rays selected in the third round. Piasentin fits a similar profile as a young hitter who was rising up Draft boards after showing off his tools in a swing through Arizona during Spring Training. At 6-foot-3 and 200 pounds, Piasentin is a presence in the box from the left side of the plate. His standout tool is his raw power, and he can get to it. He had very impressive batting practice sessions with a wood bat in Arizona, showed he could catch up to premium velocity with a base hit to his pull side against a Royals Minor League reliever with upper-90s gas and turned around junior college competition during that Arizona trip. Not everyone is a believer in the hit tool as there is some swing-and-miss, with some scouts thinking it could take a while for him to be ready to produce good numbers as a pro. While Piasentin has a plus arm that works well from third base, it's unclear whether he'll be able to stay there. He's a bit of a plodder with limited range, so a move to first base might be in order, while some wouldn't mind seeing that arm in right field. He's committed to Miami should the Draft not work out, with some scouts thinking he could emerge as an early-round pick after a few years of college reps.

Baseball America Scouting Report - BA Grade: 50/Extreme. In 2024, Canadian prepster Nathan Flewelling put on a power-hitting show on the second day of the MLB Draft combine, then was plucked 94th overall in the draft by the Rays. This year, it very well might be Piasentin, the top-ranked Canadian prospect in the class, who follows suit and hears his name called in a similar range. The 6-foot-3, 205-pound third baseman hit several towering home runs at the combine, corroborating the present physicality, strength, raw power and impressive exit velocities that scouts saw for most of the last year. Piasentin has room to add even more to his frame. He sets up with a slightly open stance featuring a head-high handset and a quiet hand load before firing his hands through the zone with an uphill path and steeper finish. It’s a ready-made swing to drive the ball with authority in the air, leaving open the potential for double-plus raw power one day. Defensively, he’s a definite corner profile who has a chance to stick at third base with his plus arm. With two plus tools on the card and a chance for gaudy home run totals one day if he can make enough contact, Piasentin fits in rounds three through five based on talent. He’s committed to Miami. Scouting Grades: Hit: 45 | Power: 55 | Run:40 | Field: 45 | Arm: 60.

Twitter Reaction

@JoeDoyleMiLB 3B Tim Piasentin can sure backspin a baseball. Some of the best feel for launch so far today. Parked buckets of balls in the seats. Consistent barrels and 108.6 peak. Physical frame.

@mlbdraftleague Tim Piasentin to #LightsUpLetsGo The @BlueJays have selected 3B Tim Piasentin (@BaseballCANJNT) with the 143rd pick (5th rd) in the @MLBDraft! Piasentin was one of Canada’s top bats during their series against the #MLBDraftLeague in June.

@643charts Tim Piasentin has been selected in the 5th round of the #MLBDraft by the @BlueJays! At last month's MLB Draft Combine Piasentin had a 108.1 average EV.

@Damon98_ Here's Blue Jays 5th rounder Tim Piasentin launching balls into the Rogers Centre bleatures at the Blue Jays futures academy this past September. Piasentin was the winner of the derby. Perhaps foreshadowing what's to come in the future.


Image from Auburn Tigers.

Round 6 - 172nd overall. SS Eric Snow, Auburn. Bats Right, Throws Right. 5-foot-8, 188 pounds. March 10, 2004. Slot Value $383,600.

Baseball America Scouting Report - Snow began his career at South Florida where he had a standout 2023 freshman season, led the team in hitting and homered eight times. He wasn’t nearly as productive as a sophomore and transferred to Auburn for the 2025 season where he moved from a regular shortstop into a utility infield role, mostly playing third base and second. Snow’s impact at the plate more closely resembled his impressive freshman campaign. Listed at 5-foot-8, 190 pounds, Snow is undersized with a compact frame that is mostly filled out. He doesn’t have loud tools, but he is an excellent contact hitter who doesn’t miss a fastball and rarely swings and misses inside the strike zone. His power is limited and he’s not a burner, but he does a lot of things well on the field, competes in the box and has the hands to play all over the infield. His fringy arm strength might make second base his best defensive fit at the next level.

Twitter Reaction

@jeffMLBdraft Eric Snow is Ernie Clement part 2 and just went to Toronto.

@discussbaseball Eric Snow going north of the border just makes sense (hence the last name). 5’8”, 188 with a compact body, smooth movements. OPS was .896 at Auburn in ‘25. Handled the CCBL very well.

@OrcaBaseball On Day 2 of the #MLBDraft, the Toronto Blue Jays have selected Micah Bucknam, Tim Piasentin, Eric Snow. Bucknam and Snow are college players and likely gives the Blue Jays some room to sign Piasentin who has huge upside with the bat at 3B.


Image from Auburn Tigers.

Round 7- 202nd overall. RHP Dylan Watts, Auburn. Bats Right, Throws Right. 6-foot-4, 193 pounds. Born July 15, 2004. Slot Value $299,900.

Baseball America Scouting Report - Watts is a 6-foot-4, 205-pound righthander who began his career at Tacoma (Wash.) Community JC in 2023. The Brewers drafted him in the 18th round in 2023, but instead of signing Watts went to Auburn where he pitched mostly in the bullpen for the next two years. Watts’ career 7.25 ERA at Auburn is underwhelming, but teams are intrigued with his pure arm talent. He sits around 95 mph with his fastball and has been up to 99 at peak velocity. He also generated a miss rate north of 50% with his hard and tight mid-80s slider. His mid-80s fading changeup is a real third pitch as well. Watts showed solid control in his 2025 draft season.

Twitter Reaction

@Damon98_ Dylan Watts is a pure reliever. He's the money saver pick seeing as Piasentin likely comes in over slot. Also leaves some wiggle room to take another upside shot later on.


Image from UNC Greensboro.

Round 8 - 232nd overall. RHP Danny Thompson Jr., UNC Greensboro. Bats Right, Throws Right. 6-foot-0, 180 pounds. Born August 9, 2002. Slot Value $238,600.

Baseball America Scouting Report - Thompson is a 6-foot, 180-pound righthanded reliever who had his best season in 2025, his second at UNC Greensboro. He posted a 3.79 ERA with 87 strikeouts to 24 walks over 61.2 innings, nearly all in relief. A two-pitch arm, Thompson leans on a mid-90s fastball with solid life and a mid-80s gyro slider that generates swings and misses. He turns 23 in August and projects as a pro reliever, which could enable a quicker ascent through a system.



Image from HailState.com

Round 9 - 262nd overall. RHP Karson Ligon, Mississippi State. Bats Right, Throws Right. 6-foot-1, 210 pounds. Born February 14, 2023. Slot Value $206,900.

Baseball America Scouting Report - After spending much of the 2024 season pitching in relief, Ligon returned to the rotation this spring and pitched to a 5.40 ERA with a career-high 73 strikeouts to 29 walks across 56.2 innings. Ligon’s fastball sits in the mid-90s and has been up to 98, but his secondaries are his bread-and-butter offerings. His gyro slider generated a 30% whiff rate, while his mid-to-upper-80s changeup consistently flashes plus and garnered a 48% whiff rate.

Twitter Reaction

@Damon98_ Ligon didn't avoid walks this year (29 in 56.2 IP) but he showed off really good stuff that missed bats at a high clip. The slider is filthy, and the fastball velocity has ticked up each year since 2021. Blue Jays pitching development could have some fun with this pick.


Image from USDToreros.com

Round 10 - 292nd overall. OF Austin Smith, University of San Diego. Bats Left, Throws Left. 5-foot-11, 185 pounds. Born April 11, 2003. Slot Value $193,500.

Coverage of rounds 11-20 can be found right here.
2025 MLB Draft - Day 2, Rounds 4-10 | 24 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
mendocino - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 11:39 AM EDT (#463606) #
Buckham mlb draft tracker fast
Gerry - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 11:44 AM EDT (#463607) #
Canadian SP, from BC. Can be a bit wild.
Marc Hulet - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 11:50 AM EDT (#463608) #
Bucknam sounds an awful lot like CJ Van Eyk - good breaking balls but fastball is straight as a pin. Either you give up velo for movement or you end up in the bullpen. Still waiting on Van Eyk to become a reliever... as he was exposed, as expected, in AAA.
hypobole - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 11:57 AM EDT (#463610) #
FG on Bucknam

Barely pitched in two seasons at LSU, transferred to Baptist and had a good season — 29% K, 9% BB, 3.67 FIP — as a starter. Has one of the best breaking balls in the draft in his 85-89 mph slider. Late, tight, vicious two-planed movement. Routinely lives on the glove-side half of the plate. Potential plus-plus offering, especially if he can polish his command a little more. Fastball sits 93-94 without great movement. Was reaching back for 96 against his old mates at Baton Rouge regional. Slower curveball with in-zone utility, changeup feel is lacking. High-effort, relatively violent delivery creates relief risk.
mendocino - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 12:00 PM EDT (#463611) #
I'll wait and see what these picks are signing for
mendocino - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 12:07 PM EDT (#463612) #
Canada
metafour - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 12:08 PM EDT (#463613) #
The Jays just took the top Canadian HS kid: 3B Tim Piasentin from Alberta.
hypobole - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 12:10 PM EDT (#463614) #
Question: Bucknam ends up as a reliever and averages 1 bWAR per season during his 6 years of team control. Success or failure?
greenfrog - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 12:14 PM EDT (#463615) #
If the Blue Jays select any more Canadians, we might have to start calling this the “elbows up” draft.
metafour - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 12:15 PM EDT (#463616) #
As a 4th round pick, that is an easy success.

1 WAR is worth what, $8M in 2025 on the open market?
greenfrog - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 12:24 PM EDT (#463617) #
WAR may not be a great measure of reliever value, and you would also want to know how many innings the reliever pitched (30? 50? 70?), but in general a 1 WAR relief pitcher would probably be pretty decent/useful.
John Northey - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 12:48 PM EDT (#463623) #
Just checked and JoJo's twin brother - Jacob Parker - has yet to be drafted. Wonder if he indicated he doesn't plan to sign or something. I suspect the Jays might grab him in rounds 11-20 then so he doesn't affect the cap if he doesn't sign. Top undrafted is Jack Bauer at #44 now. 184 guys drafted as I type so Jacob Parker should've been taken by now if seen as signable.
hypobole - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 01:15 PM EDT (#463625) #
I agree metafour. Only 47 relievers managed 1 fWAR last year. Plus when factoring in injuries and the general year-to-year up and down nature of relievers 6 fWAR would definitely be a success.
GabrielSyme - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 01:21 PM EDT (#463628) #
Eric Snow definitely feels like a very Jays pick. Pretty decent hit tool in both the Cape and the SEC, lots of progress in improving his BB:K ratio over his college career.

More and more things have to go right as you get deeper into the draft for a pick to carve out a useful major league career, and while Snow doesn't seem to have much upside, he seems like a decent choice for this range. Hard to be excited though.
Glevin - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 01:29 PM EDT (#463630) #
A reliever with 6 WAR would be a first round success.
Mike Green - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 01:33 PM EDT (#463633) #
From 2019-25 (about 6 seasons when one accounts for the partial 2020 and 2025), there have been just 9 relievers who have averaged meaningfully more than 1 fWAR per year: Clase, Hader, Hendriks, Iglesias, D. Williams, Diaz, Pressly, Chapman and Jansen (Chapman and Jansen averaged 1.2 fWAR per year). These would be the best closers in baseball over the period.

Pete Fairbanks, for instance, averaged just under 1 fWAR per year over this period.
scottt - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 01:38 PM EDT (#463636) #
Watts looks like a reliever and I don't mind that.
hypobole - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 02:59 PM EDT (#463642) #
4 of 5 bats are lefty. All 4 pitchers righty. Coincidence? I don't think so. But yeah, probably.
Marc Hulet - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 03:10 PM EDT (#463645) #
Other than JoJo, this is a very middling draft so I hope they're building up slot capital to do something interesting post-10th round... otherwise, I don't get it.
John Northey - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 03:23 PM EDT (#463647) #
For the Jays almost any success from the 4th round would be a big deal - the best 4th round pick by the Jays ever was Casey Janssen (a reliever mostly) from the 2004 draft who got 7.4 WAR lifetime. Another reliever, Sam Dyson is 2nd in WAR at 5.9. For some reason the 4th round has sucked throughout Jays history, over multiple GM's. 5th has been a WOW one with Stieb, Hentgen, Young, Timlin all 19+ WAR guys, then decent guys like Biggio, Lane Thomas, and Marc Rzepczynski got 500+ games in the majors. Go figure. Round 4 just 1 guy got 500+ games - Ryan Goins, a backup infielder. Nick Frasso is a 4th who many thought the Jays would regret trading but has yet to reach at 26 and has a 5.81 ERA in AAA for the Dodgers (5 BB/9 6.7 K/9 after missing 2024 due to injuries). Ryan Jennings (class of 2022) is damn close - AA/AAA this year 2.83 combined ERA 6.5 BB/9 (yikes) vs 11.3 K/9 (nice), someone needs to give the kid a map of the strike zone.
Gerry - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 03:36 PM EDT (#463648) #
The 8th, 9th and 10th round picks are all senior signs and Thompson is a 5 yr senior. The Jays should save around $500,000 there.
bpoz - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 03:47 PM EDT (#463649) #
Shapiro's team has done very well saving money in the latter part of the 4-10th round.
metafour - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 03:59 PM EDT (#463650) #
Marc, what exactly do you find middling about Tim Piasentin? His profile looks like a slightly smaller, less athletic version of Quentin Young who has garnered huge hype (and went to the Twins in the 50's). Otherwise its the same big power, swing/miss concern, big arm package at 3B/RF.

To me that pick isn't being talked about enough. He has apparently already toyed with ~110 mph EV's and was crushing balls at the Combine.
Kelekin - Monday, July 14 2025 @ 04:29 PM EDT (#463651) #
It's not uncommon for the first drafts under a new drafting group to be a bit poor while they find their footing. We also lack a 2nd round pick, and a lot of early picks here are high probability boom/bust. Spencer is an interesting risk in the 11th.

This feels like one of those drafts where we'll either get a star, or nothing at all. And that's fine.
2025 MLB Draft - Day 2, Rounds 4-10 | 24 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.