Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine
Today, as part of the BBLVPAs, Batter's Box salutes its 2003 Mis-Managers of the Year.

This year, there was absolutely no contest as to who the voters would pick. In two near-unanimous landslides, Jerry Manuel and Larry Bowa were selected as Mis-Managers of the year. Manuel received seven of nine first-place votes, Bowa eight of nine.


Larry Bowa - 2003 NL Mis-Manager of the Year

What more can be said about Larry Bowa that hasn't already been said? Lawrence Robert Bowa, as everyone knows, was for many years a classic good-field, no-hit shortstop for the Phillies and later the Cubs. He has since found his niche as a famously splenetic manager, and was voted NL Manager of the Year in 2001. In 2003, his third season as the Phillies skipper, Bowa managed to outdo himself, and produced the most notable performance of his career. Given a multitude of new and expensive talent (including $85 million for Jim Thome, $17 million for David Bell, $24 million to re-sign Mike Lieberthal, a $9.9 million contract for new acquisition Kevin Millwood, Bobby Abreu beginning a $64 million contract, and $50 million to re-sign Pat Burrell) many thought that the Phillies should cruise to a playoff spot. Instead, Bell and Burrell flopped, and the Phillies finished 86-76 and missed the playoffs when they were swept in a crucial three-game series by the Marlins at the end of September.

Along the way, Bowa had more of his characteristic freak-outs, including a memorable meltdown on August 28 after a 4-0 loss to the Expos. At a closed-door meeting, reporters outside the clubhouse could hear Bowa scream so loudly that his obscenities were audible over a pumping clubhouse stereo. Ironically, immediately before that game Bowa said that "As bad as things have gone - and they've gone bad - believe me, I'm going to give myself a star because I could go crazy right now." Jack McKeon later indicated that the freak-out was a sign that Bowa was "panicking", and though McKeon later withdrew that remark, it turned out to be prescient.

GM Ed Wade has given Bowa his vote of confidence, so we may yet have Larry to kick around for a while yet. Team insiders, quoted anonymously, have described there being "not any trust between the players and [Bowa] and the coaches," and that Bowa's yelling and screaming contributes to that. Should be a fun 2004... all that talent hasn't gone anywhere.

Fact File : Larry Bowa's 2003 Philadelphia Phillies


86-76, 15 games behind, 5 out of Wild Card.
Pythagorean Record of 91-71 (missed by 5 games)
20-18 in 1-run games, 10-3 in extra innings


Diamond Mind Baseball 2003 Prediction :
91-71, First Place in NL East,
62% chance of winning NL East,
72.6% chance of making playoffs




Jerry Manuel - 2003 AL Mis-Manager Of The Year

Unlike Larry Bowa, Jerry Manuel wasn't able to weather the storm of having a talented and promising team fall short of the playoffs. Manuel was fired the day after the regular season ended.

Unlike Bowa, who is easily pegged as Billy Martin without the Billy Martin, Jerry Manuel is something of an enigma despite a fine career as a manager and a Manager of the Year winner (in 2000). The White Sox manager since 1998, he managed to lead the team to four second-place finishes and only one pennant in that time - the best way to guarantee your firing. In fact, the instant the White Sox were eliminated, Manuel understood that there was no way he would not be fired, acknowledging that nothing could save his future.

It's unfortunate, but Manuel's just not a guy you can poke much fun at. An interesting, contemplative man, Manuel simply finished second too many times, and was saddled with an oddball cast of players this year, many of whom have been charged with less-than-perfect dedication in the past. Whatever the reason, this team badly underachieved.

Fact File : Jerry Manuel's 2003 Chicago White Sox


86-76, 4 games behind, 9 out of Wild Card.
Pythagorean Record of 89-73 (missed by 3 games)
18-22 in 1-run games, 8-5 in extra innings


Diamond Mind Baseball 2003 Prediction :
86-76, Second Place in AL Central,
34% chance of winning AL Central,
34% chance of making playoffs




BBLVPA 2003 Mis-Manager of the Year Voting (Top 5 only)

Nine votes were received; each voter was asked to rank three choices, points awarded on a 5-3-1 basis.


American League


Manager 1st 2nd 3rd Points


Jerry Manuel 7 1 0 38
Alan Trammell 0 4 1 13
Mike Scioscia 0 3 0 9
Mike Hargrove 1 0 1 6
Bob Melvin 1 0 1 6


National League


Manager 1st 2nd 3rd Points


Larry Bowa 8 0 0 40
Bob Boone 1 0 3 9
Tony LaRussa 0 2 1 7
Jeff Torborg 0 2 0 6
Jimy Williams 0 1 2 5
BBLVPAs : Mis-Managers Of The Year | 13 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Craig B - Thursday, October 16 2003 @ 03:24 PM EDT (#21335) #
Up next, we will be presenting the 2003 Allan Travers Awards, for the worst pitcher in either league. Stay tuned.
_Ryan - Thursday, October 16 2003 @ 03:38 PM EDT (#21336) #
Larry Bowa? I never expected much from the Phillies this year.
Coach - Thursday, October 16 2003 @ 04:14 PM EDT (#21337) #
At a closed-door meeting, reporters outside the clubhouse could hear Bowa scream so loudly that his obscenities were audible over a pumping clubhouse stereo. Ironically, immediately before that game Bowa said that "As bad as things have gone - and they've gone bad - believe me, I'm going to give myself a star because I could go crazy right now."

Ryan, that kind of behaviour, the Tyler Houston mess, and many other childish incidents earned my vote. I even proposed that Bowa get a Lifetime Underachievement Award from the Mis-Manager committee. I didn't even consider the standings, though I believe that Casey Stengel would have managed the '03 Phils into the playoffs, despite the Perfesser's demised condition.

Manuel's just not a guy you can poke much fun at

There's nothing funny about his effect on a bullpen. Only Jerry would have pushed the panic button on Keith Foulke last May. Obviously, he pushed for the Koch trade, which underlined his stupidity this season, as he managed to destroy Koch's fragile psyche while Foulke proved what everyone knows but Jerry. Though the NL had all the best candidates for this prestigious award, Manuel is a deserving winner.
_Jeff Torborg - Thursday, October 16 2003 @ 04:30 PM EDT (#21338) #
Jeebus!

How many young pitchers' arms do I have to shred before I get even one frickin' first place vote?

brought to you by Andrew Edwards
_Mick - Thursday, October 16 2003 @ 06:27 PM EDT (#21339) #
Just for the record, I really, really want to vote for John Hart.
_Nigel - Thursday, October 16 2003 @ 06:32 PM EDT (#21340) #
If you were taking a longer term view of things I would give Dusty Baker my vote. He did nothing to develop his younger position players (except maybe Patterson) and his young pitchers were whipped. He won his division so I guess there is no room to vote for him, but I really would not like him to be the manager of my favourite team.
_Steve Birnie - Thursday, October 16 2003 @ 10:00 PM EDT (#21341) #
I'm surprised Jimy One M didn't get any votes. Houston had the worst differential between pythagorean results and actual results. And it's Jimy.
_Steve Birnie - Thursday, October 16 2003 @ 10:01 PM EDT (#21342) #
Sorry...meant to say 'more votes'
_benum - Friday, October 17 2003 @ 03:15 PM EDT (#21343) #
With the benefit of an extra 24 hours of data, I'm going to go with Grady Little...
_bob mong - Tuesday, October 28 2003 @ 11:25 AM EST (#21344) #
http://vdub_bobby.blogspot.com
Houston had the worst differential between pythagorean results and actual results.

I have yet to see any explanation for how the difference between pyth results and actual results can be attributed to the manager. Nor have I seen any evidence supporting such a thesis. The pyth isn't reality, it is a model for reality.
_coliver - Monday, November 24 2003 @ 12:41 PM EST (#21345) #
Mis-manager?

JIMY WILLIAMS, of course!
_Wes - Monday, November 24 2003 @ 01:47 PM EST (#21346) #
Jimy Williams: The Blum Ensberg fiasco cost me my fantasy pool.
Mike Green - Monday, November 24 2003 @ 02:53 PM EST (#21347) #
Bob Mong,
I can't think of how you would test the thesis that managers play a role in the differential between actual w-l and pythag.

How about looking at it another way? The Astros were below .500 (19-21) in one-run games despite having a very strong bullpen, and a winning ballclub. Yes, it could be simply dumb luck, but here in Toronto we remember the Williams years well (last game of the season 1987, pennant still up for grabs, top of ninth, two outs, nobody on and Toronto down by 1 run, Jimy has to choose a pinch-hitter and points at Garth Iorg rather than Cecil Fielder). Blum instead of Ensberg was no accident.
BBLVPAs : Mis-Managers Of The Year | 13 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.